Holiday dates are open. Thanksgiving and Christmas fill up fast, so message us early.
How to orderCustom cakes · Brooklyn & Staten Island
Your personal cake design, made with organic ingredients.
Birthday cakes, bento cakes, wedding cakes and full dessert tables, designed around you and baked to order.
What we bake
Every cake is designed with you. Ask for a quote.
Wedding cakes
Tiered and custom
Baby shower
Gender reveals and more
For her
Elegant and floral
Girls' cakes
Characters and themes
Boys' cakes
Heroes, sports, cars
Dessert tables
Cupcakes, sweets, desserts
For him
Bold and personal
Bento cakes
Small, sweet, giftable
Treat boxes
Strawberries, cupcakes, cookies12 flavors to choose from
Any flavor works with any design.
- Red velvet
- Chocolate honey
- Vanilla berry
- Oreo
- Vanilla lemon
- Snickers
- Blueberry
- Honey cake
- Pistachio berry
- Honey berry
- Chocolate berry
- Carrot cake
Tell us about allergies when you order.
Recent work
What customers say
4.5 stars from 8 reviews on Google
“Beautiful cake for my niece’s baby shower. It was so delicious. I can’t wait for the next occasion to order again.”
“I have ordered cakes several times. They are incredible! Natalia makes designs of any complexity. The cakes are very tasty.”
“I love this bakery! Everything I’ve tried so far has been super fresh and tasty.”
What a cake costs
Final price depends on your design. Ask for an exact quote.
- from $150
6-inch cake
4 lb · 6–8 servings - from $200
7-inch cake
6 lb · about 10 servings - from $250
8-inch cake
8 lb · about 15 servings - from $300
9-inch cake
10 lb · about 20 servings - from $350
10-inch cake
12 lb · about 25 servings - from $400
11-inch cake
14 lb · about 30 servings - from $500
2-tier cakes
From 10 lb · weddings and large parties - $80–$100
Cupcakes
Per dozen · price depends on decoration - $70
Chocolate strawberries
Per dozen - $100–$110
Cakesicles
Per dozen · price depends on decoration - $120
Decorated cookies
Per dozen · custom designs
Some cakes can be frozen by request. Ask us when you order.
How to order
Reach out
DM @natalis.art.cake, call or email with your date, guest count and inspiration photos.
Get your quote
We reply within 24 hours with a design idea and exact price.
Book ahead
At least 1 week ahead, weddings 2 weeks. Delivery around New York.
Holiday dates are open. Thanksgiving and Christmas fill up fast, so message us early. Tell us about any allergies when you order.
Pickup and delivery
Bay Ridge
Brooklyn, NY
Lorimer Street
Brooklyn, NY
Rossville
Staten Island, NY
We also deliver around New York for an additional fee, quoted with your order. Exact address and pickup time are shared once your order is confirmed.